Giving this vote to the Turtles. I had more fun with them as a kid than I did with a Frisbee...probably because I was kind of uncoordinated.

I never could get a Frisbee to fly straight.

I had a bunch of the Ninja Turtle figures. Probably still do somewhere... I was quite the Turtle fan, even before they were massively popular.

But I'm voting for the Frisbee. It's one of the few outside toys I can really get in to....

Tie-Breakers:

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
710 nomination points
10 * 4 nominators beyond the first = 40 points
89% of 2 for beating See 'n Say in round 1 = 5 points minimum for victory
100% of 110 for shutting out Monster in My Pocket in round 2 = 110 points
== 865 points

Frisbee
30 nomination points
10 * 1 nominator beyond the first = 10 points
70% of 160 for beating Construx in round 1 = 112 points
60% of 9 for beating Mr. Potato Head in round 2 = 5 points
== 157 points

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles wins in tie-breakers.